Paul Marcuccitti is a passionate
soccer fan from Australia who will share his views about the World Cup in this column.
Read earlier columns
Here we go ... sort of
Since the Asian Cup ended, I've spent some time pondering what an odd
period this is in the World Cup cycle.
The international football focus in the twelve months between the 2007 and
2008 European off-seasons is mainly on continental championships -
CONCACAF and CONMEBOL have also held theirs; Africa's finals have just
been played; and UEFA's finals will be in June.
But qualification for South Africa 2010 is underway too. By the time
qualifiers begin in Europe, a lot of nations around the rest of the world
will have been eliminated.
Indeed, in my main zones of interest, Asia and Oceania, more than half of
the teams that entered the World Cup are out already.
That isn't necessarily a problem. The real pity is that a lot of these
teams either don't get to play a qualifier in front of their home fans -
or their campaign is over after just two matches.
I know, I know, the lack of money is the problem for a lot of smaller
national federations. But although I don't have the answers, there must be
a better way.
The first 2010 World Cup qualifiers to be played anywhere were held in
Oceania last August at the South Pacific Games in Samoa. Nine OFC
countries played for the right to join New Zealand in the home-and-away
final round of four teams.
That tournament eliminated six teams and five of them didn't get the
chance to play a home match. One of those teams was Solomon Islands - the
darling of the 2006 Oceania qualifiers. Yes, just two years after hosting
Australia in Honiara in a playoff to decide the winner of OFC's 2006 World
Cup qualification series, the Solomons' 2010 campaign was over.
The three teams that did advance to the next round were Fiji, Vanuatu and
the rapidly improving New Caledonia. We've nearly reached the half-way
mark of this round and the New Zealenders are looking good with a maximum
9 points from 3 matches. Realistically, only New Caledonia (4 points from
2 matches) can catch them.
The winner of the group advances to a playoff with the team that finishes
5th in Asia. Sadly, the original plan to add the Oceanic winner to one of
Asia's final groups was shelved. (As I'm sure most of you would be aware,
decisions about Oceania's World Cup qualifying path are so rarely
The current round of Asian qualifiers marks the return to World Cup action
of the five teams in the confederation that made it to Germany in 2006:
Australia, South Korea, Saudi Arabia, Japan and Iran.
To get to this point, Asia has, thus far, employed a knockout system to
trim its other 38 entrants to 15 so that this first group phase includes
20 teams (in 5 groups of 4). The top two from each group advance to the
final group phase (2 groups of 5) and they will produce four teams that
qualify for South Africa and one other team that gets another chance in a
playoff against the winner of Oceania.
For 2006, Asia had 32 teams in its first group phase. Reducing it to 20 is
not a step in the right direction.
The casualties from the knockout rounds included Vietnam, quarter finalist
at last year's Asian Cup. Unfortunately for the Vietnamese, the only
criterion for seeding teams was performance in qualifiers for 2006. That
meant Vietnam was seeded 25th and the draw for the first knockout round
threw teams seeded between 25 and 43 against teams seeded between 6 and
24. The Vietnamese drew United Arab Emirates and that was the end of that.
Had they been seeded 23rd, they might have played one of the weaker teams
like Timor-Leste (as Hong Kong did) and might have at least extended their
qualification effort to the next knockout round.
Kyrgyzstan is gone too. Now you may ask "who?" or say "so what", but the
Kyrgyz were only eliminated by Jordan after penalties (after two legs, the
teams finished level). That's a result that suggests that we should have
seen more of Kyrgyzstan. (Jordan gave Iran a real fright in the 2006
qualifiers and is one of the better teams in Asia.)
Before I talk about the current round of Asian qualifying, let me have
just one more whinge. As mentioned, the current group phase will produce
10 teams that advance to the next round (2 groups of 5).
Now, I know that groups of 5 teams are sometimes unavoidable but surely
groups of 4 are immeasurably better. The round could easily have been
extended to 12 teams with 3 group winners qualifying for the finals and 3
runners-up going into playoffs (2 against each other with the other team
playing the winner of Oceania).
The 5-team groups mean an unwieldy 10 rounds and, after that, one Asian
team will play 4 more matches. The two 3rd-place getters play each other
for the right to play the Oceania winner for a final chance to qualify.
The Asian team that ends up playing the Oceania winner will have played at
least 18 matches in its effort to qualify; possibly 20 or 22 if it had to
play in the early knockout rounds. And you thought qualifying through
CONMEBOL was a marathon.
Last week, the first group phase kicked off with the following five groups:
Group 1 - Australia, China, Iraq, Qatar
Group 2 - Japan, Bahrain, Oman, Thailand
Group 3 - South Korea, North Korea, Jordan, Turkmenistan
Group 4 - Saudi Arabia, Uzbekistan, Lebanon, Singapore
Group 5 - Iran, Kuwait, United Arab Emirates, Syria
The order of the teams is highest seed to lowest. So, for instance, in
Group 5, Iran is the highest seed, Kuwait is the second-highest, etc.
I initially felt that the top two seeds would advance in each group,
except for Group 1 where I'd have picked Australia and Iraq to deny China.
But it's amazing how just one round of matches can make you quickly
Group 1 was immediately labelled the Group of Death with Australia (which
qualified for 2006) joined by China (which qualified for 2002) and Iraq
(Asian champions). Then you have Qatar, a team that is unlikely to qualify
for the next phase but extremely likely to take points off other teams.
The Qataris didn't open well losing 0-3 in Australia but they were missing
some of their best players. They will be far more difficult to beat in
China, a team that has so far failed to build on its success in qualifying
for the 2002 World Cup finals, grabbed a small edge over Iraq by holding
the Asian Champions to a 1-1 draw in Dubai (which is where the Iraqis are
playing their home matches). Next month's round of matches sees China host
Australia and Qatar at home against Iraq. It could be fascinating.
Group 2 should be no pushover for Japan and Bahrain. Oman recorded draws
against both Australia and Iraq at last year's Asian Cup while Thailand
narrowly missed a place in the quarter finals. Round one, however, was
good for the favourites. After an early scare, Japan defeated Thailand 4-1
in Saitama; and Bahrain scored a 1-0 win in Oman.
Oman is a well-organised team but struggles in front of goal. That
deficiency is likely to derail its challenge for a place in the final 10.
If the Thais have any chance of succeeding, they simply must defeat
Bahrain when the two teams meet in Bangkok next month.
Group 3 brings the excitement of the two Koreas being drawn together.
Matches between South Korea and North Korea aren't exactly rare but the
two teams haven't faced each other in a World Cup qualifier since 1993.
And their only meetings in World Cup qualifiers have been at neutral
Both Koreas should advance. Turkmenistan has declined since its
competitive performance in the 2004 Asian Championship while Jordan lacks
consistency. The first round went to plan: South Korea defeated
Turkmenistan 4-0 at home; North Korea scored a 1-0 win away to Jordan. The
two Koreas meet in Pyongyang next month in a match that will attract much
interest around Asia.
Group 4 looks straightforward for Saudi Arabia, traditionally a strong
performer in World Cup qualifying, and Uzbekistan, a team that poses a
real threat to Asia's usual suspects (and is surely due for some luck).
Lebanon isn't a bad team but it's not in the same class. Not helping the
Lebanese players is that they've had few competitive games of late with
war forcing them to withdraw from Asian Championship qualifiers in 2006.
Singapore is an improving team and the lowest seed in Asia (29th) to reach
this stage. The Singaporeans might be good enough to test the group's big
guns but reaching the final 10 will be beyond them. Last week Saudi Arabia
defeated Singapore 2-0 at home while Uzbekistan won 1-0 in Lebanon.
Group 5 may not be called the Group of Death but it might turn out that
way. Iran always seems to be a better team on paper than it is on the
field. The Iranians' performances at the last World Cup and in last year's
Asian Cup were not as good as had been expected. Then there's little to
separate Kuwait, UAE and Syria.
Of the three, UAE was the only one to qualify for the Asian Championship
but Kuwait had the misfortune of drawing Bahrain and Australia in its
qualification group while Syria got stuck with Iran and South Korea.
Last week, Syria drew 0-0 in Iran while UAE recorded a 2-0 home win over
Kuwait. Next month sees Syria v UAE and Kuwait v Iran. If you can predict
how things will finish up in this group, you're a better pundit than me.
The next round of matches is on March 26 but then that will be it for a
little while. The last four match days of this group phase will all be in
June and after that we'll know which ten teams will kick off the next
phase of Asian qualifiers later this year.
By then, it might actually feel like we're well and truly into the run up
to the World Cup finals.
Info on how
the World Cup was founded and about the trophy as well.
on every match in every tournament.
Interesting columns about the past, present and future of the World Cup.
with appearances in the World Cup. Detailed info on every country.
of many of the most influential players in history.
An A-Z collection
of strange and different stories in World Cup history.
A big collection
of various statistics and records.
since it was introduced in 1966.
knowledge about the WC. Three different levels. No prizes, just for fun.
lots of stuff. For instance Best Goals, Best Players and Best Matches.
of links to other soccer sites with World Cup connection.
and buttons for you to link to us if you want.
A little information
on who keeps this site available.