Pierre Boisrond

Pierre Boisrond has followed soccer and the World Cup closely for many years and also writes for other websites. We at PWC are proud to have him as a columnist. He will share his views about the past, present and future of the World Cup.

Mail Pierre

Read earlier columns

Controversial coaching decisions - fair on the players?

    Over the years, soccerfans have witnessed coaches who completely refuse to bring certain players. That seems to happen a lot in South American National Teams. It has happened with Brazil and also with Argentina. In the case of Brazil, a controversial decision by Zagallo and Zico cost Romario the 1998 World Cup. For some strange reasons, Passarella refused to call Fernando Redondo for France 1998. These sorts of silly decisions only hurt the games and prevent the fans around the world to see great players who are capable of furnishing something really special on the football pitch.

    Brazil and Argentina will have to face each other on September 5th and the rendezvous for this grandiose South American derby will be at the River Plate Monumental Stadium. However, Marcelo Bielsa, the Argentine national coach, decided to spoil the party since he had refused to call the Argentine Super Star, Gabriel Omar Batistuta, for this game. Bielsa deliberately decided to spoil the party for the fans of the round ball. The question that troubled me is a simple “Why?”

    These days, when a fan talks about Argentina; one knows that this fan has to mention the name of Batistuta. With a lame excuse, Bielsa had decided not call Batigol and therefore prevented the fans to see the tandem duo “Bati-Crespo”. Sometimes, one wonders why these coaches are making so many bad decisions. In the case of Bielsa, Argentina is already qualified, now is the time for him to start using the “Duo”. Many fans were convinced that Batigol would have received the call, but these fans ended up being disappointed by the coach of the “Albiceleste”.

    The verb that Bielsa tends to conjugate is that Crespo and Batistuta cannot play together. This is an absurd statement that lament many international coaches. It would have been a dream for international coaches to have these two players in their squad. It is quite impossible for myself to understand this phenomenon. There’s no logical reasoning behind Bielsa’s decision. The knee injury is no longer an issue for the world's deadliest striker. It’s not a contest between Crespo and Batistuta but a contest between Bielsa and Batistuta.

    Bielsa can easily say that his coaching principles worked since Argentina had already qualified. But, a coach should be able to make accommodations. In a derby between Argentina and Brazil, the best players must be there if they can play. These players will give the games a different meaning and will render it very special so the fans around the world can enjoy it. When the best players in the world step on the soccer pitch, everyone expects some magnificent moves like the ones we have seen from Rivaldo, Veron, Crespo, Bati or Denilson who did get rid of the Paraguayan defender to set a beauty for Rivaldo, an idol of the Ex-Argentine International, Diego Armando Maradona. Coaches must put special formulas aside and let the players take the games to the highest level.

    This Bielsa will destroy the harmony of the Albiceleste and must be really careful in his decisions. At that level, there’s no excuse for leaving Bati out. It is time for Bielsa to put Batigol and Crespo on the pitch. It is time to do it. If not, when will that happen, in Korea-Japan? I hope not. So far, the Bielsa era had caused Argentina three losses against Brazil. Bielsa had only won one game against Brazil. After all we all know that Brazil is Brazil and the Brazilians are not going to make it easy for the Argentines. In any great game, great players do rise to the expectations like Karl Heinz Rummenigue did it against the France of Michel Platini in 1982; like Diego Armando Maradona did against a talented Australian team to qualify Argentina for the 1994 World Cup; like Rivaldo and Denilson did against Paraguay to restore the hope of the Brazilian fans and give Brazil a chance to be in Korea-Japan 2002; Like Dennis Bergkamp did against Argentina in France 98 to give the Netherlands a chance to face Brazil in the semi-final; Like Paolo Rossi did in Spain 82 against the talented Brazilian team conducted by Arthur Coimbra (Zico) and a superb doctor better known as Socrates, or should I steal the line from the Haitian's commentators who called him “Docteur Socrates.” I could go on and on. It’s all about passion, my dear readers; it’s all about the love for the game; that's what makes derbies very special. When there are derbies, fans do expect to see the best players. When there are derbies among national teams, the whole country is waiting and therefore employees can go home, business shut down. It's all about passion! To really understand this one has to experience it and I do believe many of us who were not born in the USA do experience that sort of passion. If a fan still hasn't experienced this passion, I would suggest that he or she got his or her plane ticket to Buenos Aires for this September 5th derby. A national coach should never interfere with that passion and must also think about the fans, not only his or her benefits.

    The Bielsa saga is not over, it will continue. He has not called Riquelme yet, although Romy is injured. Believe me, he will call him. Riquelme should definitely have been the candidate to replace Veron; But, Bielsa is lucky on this point due to the Boca Superstar's knee injury. Remember this point, national pressure will force Bielsa to call Riquelme and to put the duo Bati-Crespo up front. Imagine an attack with Veron, Riquelme in the place of Aimar and Bati-Crespo upfront. Argentina would become like a Manchester United conducted by a sensational Veron with the eternal David Beckham; or should I say a Brazilian attack with Rivaldo, Denilson, Romario and Ronaldo! Imagine what we would have seen!

    To conclude, I must say that this week the fans will enjoy a European Derby: England vs Germany and a South American Super “Clasico”, Argentina vs. Brazil. I hope that Oliver Kahn can resist the young English Superstar, Michael Owen, if not, it could be pretty ugly for the Germans. For the Argentines, Bielsa better not go down in Buenos Aires; if not, he will be 1-4 against Brazil conducted by a talented and spectacular magician such as Rivaldo.

    Rivaldo is not going to make it easy for Argentina — Remember that Argentina has no Veron and Aimar does not convince me yet. He needs to step it up like he did against Italy this year. If he can't do that, he must be on the bench and let Gallardo run the show. With Aimar not playing well, Veron out and Bati left out things get complicated for Argentina. I would rather see Aimar replaced by Riquelme who is now the best player that Argentina has and might even be the best in the world at this very moment. Well, remember that Riquelme displayed his repertoires against Figo and company in the past Inter Continental Cup. We have to wait and see and let’s hope the coaches won’t interfere with the game by preventing the world's best players participate in games that could be historical.

See you all next time!



Info on how the World Cup was founded and about the trophy as well.
Detailed info on every match in every tournament.
Interesting columns about the past, present and future of the World Cup.
Every nation with appearances in the World Cup. Detailed info on every country.
Player profiles of many of the most influential players in history.
An A-Z collection of strange and different stories in World Cup history.
A big collection of various statistics and records.
Every mascot since it was introduced in 1966.
Test your knowledge about the WC. Three different levels. No prizes, just for fun.
Rankings of lots of stuff. For instance Best Goals, Best Players and Best Matches.
Our collection of links to other soccer sites with World Cup connection.
Some banners and buttons for you to link to us if you want.
A little information on who keeps this site available.
| '30 | '34 | '38 | '50 | '54 | '58 | '62 | '66 | '70 | '74 | '78 | '82 | '86 | '90 | '94 | '98 | '02 | '06 | '10 | '14 |
Copyrights © 1998-2014 - This website is created and maintained by Jan Alsos. It is an unofficial website not affiliated or connected in any way to FIFA. All rights reserved.